The scriptures has a complicated history together it was written hundreds of years earlier by a variety of different writer in various circumstances, thus, the answer to this concern is not totally straightforward.

You are watching: Is the bible a primary source

So, is the bible a primary source of information? Parts of the scriptures are main sources of information as castle purport come be created by the writer themselves. Other portions of the holy bible are recordings that the memory of rather who associated in the information to the author and also are thus not major sources.

There are plenty of nuances to the answer, however, which ns will check out throughout the rest of this post.

Primary and an additional Source information is typically Mixed throughout Biblical Acounts

An instance of main and an additional sources in the scriptures comes from the story that Christ’s crucifixion. In the gospel of Matthew, he records components of the story i beg your pardon he experienced first-hand and thus are main sources.

Matthew personal saw:

Jesus Christ to be taken through soldiersChrist went to GolgothaChrist was nailed come a crossChief priests, four women, soldiers, and also disciples were present at the crucifixion.The sign above Christ claimed “This is Jesus, King that the Jews”Jesus Christ died

Matthew might or may not have personally seen:

Simon, a Cyrene, was compelled to carry Christ’s cross to GolgothaThe veil that the temple was rent in twainThe conversation between Pilate and ChristThe bodies of dead saints coming ago to lifeThe conversation in between Joseph that Arimathea and also Pilate

Matthew was definitely a first-hand witness the the most vital parts of the story, yet some details in the story may or may not come native first-hand knowledge. The is vital to understand, however, the a primary source need no come native first-hand knowledge. One interview, because that example, is a main source. Matthew may have actually interviewed others that did view those events, i beg your pardon would typical his information was primary, yet we are analysis it second-hand.

Portions of the bible which are major Sources of Information

Much the the bible is to fill with spiritual teachings. They space statements of wrong and also right and also faith and also devotion. Thus, they are really not main nor second sources, but basic teachings. The stories, however, have the right to be proven as first or secondary sources.

A few examples follow:

Primary resource – Jesus healing the 10 lepers as videotaped by LukeUnknown – The story that David and Goliath was videotaped by Samuel. Samuel to be a contemporary of David, yet it is unknown if Samuel actually witnessed this event in David’s life or if it to be told come him.Primary source – Paul’s letters to Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, etc.Primary source – Christ call the sons of Zebedee come the ministry was taped by a son of Zebedee.Probably not a primary source – The entire book of Luke. Many scholars agree the the publication of Luke was written by Luke after the moment of Christ. His resources of info were most likely Paul (his missionary companion) and another resource (who scholars periodically refer to as “Q”).Etc.

Portions that the scriptures which are secondary Sources the Information

Not every one of the story in the scriptures are written by the human being in the story. For example, no part of the bible was created by Adam or Eve, or even any of their contemporaries. Adam and Eve’s story is taped in Genesis, i beg your pardon was composed by Moses in the so late 1500s BC. Thus, the entire account is a secondary source.

Another example is the works of Paul. Many of Paul’s teachings are about the plot of Christ. Paul to be not one of the original 12 disciples of Christ and also in fact was antagonistic come Christianity in his at an early stage life. Over there is no record in the holy bible of Paul ever also meeting Jesus Christ. Thus, Paul’s teachings, though an important for study and also devotion, would certainly not be taken into consideration by a researcher to it is in a primary resource of information.

Does the Biblical Translation impact the Answer?

Not necessarily. There space many old copies of the Bible and all differ slightly in detail since they were interpreted by different civilization from different original texts.

Thus, if the question is if the existing King James variation of the bible you may organize is an initial source, the answer would certainly still be mainly yes, yet that the original source has gone through a translate into which must be showed for accuracy.

For example, if a researcher interviewed someone in a international language and an interpreter interpreted it because that you, that doesn’t immediately make the information a an additional source, however it is a class of change which have to be investigated.

Was the bible Indeed created by Those who We Historically say They Were created By?

The discussion that casts doubt upon the classic understanding that these resources is that it is feasible that numerous of the publications in the bible were no actually created by the authors they to speak they were written by.

Some to speak that several of the publications were most likely ghost written under your names by others in a typical practice the the job of creating from another’s perspective.

See more: Is Cold The Absence Of Heat And Not The Other Way Around? There Is No Cold

This is feasible and go not affect my id that the holy bible contains specifically what God wants it come contain, however from an academic standpoint that would readjust the answer come this question. This question has no answer as scholars will certainly undoubtedly conflict it till the end of time, yet it go at the very least deserve come be stated in this academic look at the info in the Bible.